Maarten Ackerman, Chief Economist at Citadel, comments on South Africa’s Q2 2024 Gross Domestic Product (GDP) data announced this morning by StatsSA. South Africa’s economic growth for the second quarter of 2024 was a mere 0.4% quarter-on-quarter, reflecting a continued struggle to gain momentum. Over the last 12 months, the economy has grown by only 0.3%, a figure so low that it borders on recessionary levels, warns Maarten Ackerman, Chief Economist at Citadel.
“This sluggish performance underscores the ongoing economic challenges that the country faces,” says Ackerman.
While today’s GDP results mark a second consecutive quarter of positive growth, following a flat Q1 2024 and a 0.3% increase in Q4 2023, the numbers highlight a persistent challenge: the economy is growing well below the population growth rate of approximately 1.5%. This discrepancy underscores the lack of significant impact from ongoing economic reforms and suggests continued social pressure and high unemployment.
Figure 1: Growth rates shared by StatsSA.
“The GDP figures don’t yet reflect the optimism we’ve seen in the financial markets since the Government of National Unity (GNU) took office. Strong returns on the Johannesburg Stock Exchange (JSE), bond market and a strengthening rand are more sentiment-driven, with market watchers hoping that the new government will address the structural barriers hindering economic growth.”
He cautions that recent data, including vehicle sales and the Purchasing Manager’s Index (PMI) index, an economic indicator that reflects the health of a country’s manufacturing and services sectors, show fundamental weaknesses in the South African economy. The data could signal that the current market rally may not be sustainable without significant economic improvements.
Notably, Q2 growth was bolstered by contributions from sectors like electricity, gas, and water, buoyed by a quarter free of load-shedding. Manufacturing and construction also showed promise, but the agricultural sector contracted by 2.1% following a high base in the previous quarter and a decline in field crops and animal products. On the expenditure side, household consumption rose by 1.4%, a positive sign despite challenging conditions. However, a concerning trend is the continued decline in gross fixed capital formation, a reflection of the business sector’s level of willingness to invest in assets that boost the economy, highlighting the need for broader investment beyond just the solar boom.
Figure 2: Slowing economic growth as shared by StatsSA.
Figure 3: StatsSA indicates which industries grew.
“The current GDP numbers reflect the ongoing structural challenges that have long hindered South Africa’s economic progress. Despite some positive developments, such as the emergence of the GNU and optimistic market sentiment, the economy remains constrained. Significant work is still required to address these structural challenges and achieve sustainable economic growth above 2.5%. Without this and the current optimism surrounding the GNU, South African asset classes could face substantial risks.” Ackerman concludes.